First Coffee Find Your Match

Evangelical Community

Meet your Evangelical match —

Evangelical
coffee dates

Your matchmaker

We find the
right person for you

Our team reads your preferences and finds one person genuinely worth meeting from the Evangelical community. Faith first — always.

Find your match
R.J.
Compatible

Brooklyn, NY

R.J., 34

Product Manager

Evangelical
P.S.
Compatible

Upper West Side

P.S., 36

Data Scientist

Evangelical

Match → Date → Done

Match on Monday,
meet by Saturday

Every match is a real date — confirmed and waiting. Our concierge picks the cafe and time. You just show up.

Find your match
You, Emma, Concierge

Hi both! I found a great cafe for you two. How does Saturday at 2pm work?

Concierge

Works for me!

Saturday sounds perfect

Emma

You're all set! Saturday 2pm at a great local cafe. Have a wonderful time!

Concierge

Save the reveal for the cafe

Save the spark
for the cafe

Upload a selfie and get an illustrated avatar in 20 seconds. The real spark happens in person, not on a screen.

Find your match
Before
Photo
After
Avatar
Before
Photo
After
Avatar

From our members

Real stories from real first dates.

Grace

Grace, 35

Dallas

"Christian Mingle had been a waste of my weekends for two years. Every promising conversation either faded out or turned into a situationship. Matched here and was at a café in Dallas within a week. No warm-up chat. Just a real date."

Rachel

Rachel, 33

"Someone else sorted the café near my church in Chicago and sent me the details. I just showed up. The faith was already shared — no awkward third-date conversation about what I actually believe. We just talked. It was easy."

Josh

Josh, 34

Atlanta

"I was skeptical, honestly. Another app claiming to be different. But both of us confirmed, both showed up in Atlanta, and she was the first match I'd had in years who was actually serious about her walk. No ghosting after the match."

Caleb

Caleb, 36

Houston

"She already shared the faith — no screening, no hoping she'd be okay with church mattering to me. We talked about real things immediately. Asked her to coffee again before I'd finished mine."

Simple pricing

Pay per date.
No subscription.

First Coffee

$ 33

per date

  • Curated match from your community
  • Cafe selected for you
  • Full refund if canceled
Get matched

Your weekends deserve better than swiping.

One person who already shares what matters. One cafe. One real conversation.

Get matched